Blog

Resources

CGI comparison of ECT and TMS Therapy

Exploring Brain Stimulation Therapies: A Comparative Analysis of TMS and ECT in Mental Health Treatment"

May 05, 17112 min read

"Small, baby steps each day add up to huge, giant leaps over time. So, please keep going. Do NOT give up." - T.D.P

CGI of explanation of differences between ECT and TMS

Introduction:

The landscape of mental health treatments delves into the distinct realms of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) and Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT), creating a pivotal point of consideration. Despite both focusing on mood disorders, their modes of action, side effects, and treatment outcomes diverge significantly. This article aims to offer a thorough examination of the key distinctions between TMS and ECT.

CGI showing a a lightening bolt and scrambled detection of a brain and a calm depiction of a brain with a magnet

Treatment Differences:

When it comes to treatment mechanisms, TMS sets itself apart with its magnetic precision. Utilizing magnetic pulses, TMS precisely activates specific brain regions without inducing seizures. This approach, characterized by its non-invasiveness and targeted nature, delicately influences neural activity. In contrast, ECT relies on electrical currents to induce seizures, operating on a broader and less precise mechanism than TMS.

Side Effects: TMS vs ECT

Image showing a person's head losing puzzle pieces from brain to indicate memory loss/confusion

Considering side effects, TMS is linked to minimal adverse effects such as mild discomfort or headaches. Importantly, it avoids the memory loss or cognitive impairments often associated with ECT. Conversely, ECT comes with significant side effects, including more common and severe memory loss and cognitive impairments compared to TMS.

Administration Differences: Outpatient and Hospital

The administration process serves as another distinguishing factor between the two therapies. TMS is an outpatient procedure that does not necessitate anesthesia or hospitalization, allowing for an immediate return to daily activities. In contrast, ECT is typically administered in a hospital setting and requires anesthesia, with recovery potentially taking several hours, causing disruptions to daily life.

Treatment Path: Beginning to End Results

When examining the treatment course, TMS involves daily sessions over several weeks, with the option for maintenance sessions, offering a well-tolerated and continuous approach. On the other side, ECT demands a more intensive initial phase, coupled with variable maintenance sessions.

Image with a hand writing the text 'results' in marker

Effectiveness and relapse rates further set TMS and ECT apart. TMS has demonstrated efficacy in treating depression with lower relapse rates and milder side effects compared to ECT. While ECT can prove highly effective in cases for severe depression, it carries a higher risk of relapse and a potential for severe side effects.

Let's Summarize!

Understanding these differences holds paramount importance in making informed decisions regarding mental health treatment. Misinterpretations could lead to inaccurate expectations and inappropriate choices. By grasping these nuances, individuals can make informed decisions, ensuring a more effective and tailored approach to mental well-being.


Many people confuse these two therapy treatments quite often, but they really couldn't be any different! TMS Therapy is a more natural way to reach the root cause of depression through thorough brain mapping, several sessions for safety and efficacy, and NO harmful side effects! Thinking this treatment option for your depression is the way to go, let's try it! Together. Call or text our clinic today and see how we can help you with your mental health goals.

Mental health treatmentsTranscranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)TMSElectroconvulsive Therapy (ECT)ECTSide effects of TMS and ECTTreatment options for depressionTreatment options for anxiety/depressionWhat is the difference between ECT and TMS TherapyHow long is TMS TherapyMedication free treatment options for depression
Back to Blog

Blog

Resources

CGI comparison of ECT and TMS Therapy

Exploring Brain Stimulation Therapies: A Comparative Analysis of TMS and ECT in Mental Health Treatment"

May 05, 17112 min read

"Small, baby steps each day add up to huge, giant leaps over time. So, please keep going. Do NOT give up." - T.D.P

CGI of explanation of differences between ECT and TMS

Introduction:

The landscape of mental health treatments delves into the distinct realms of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) and Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT), creating a pivotal point of consideration. Despite both focusing on mood disorders, their modes of action, side effects, and treatment outcomes diverge significantly. This article aims to offer a thorough examination of the key distinctions between TMS and ECT.

CGI showing a a lightening bolt and scrambled detection of a brain and a calm depiction of a brain with a magnet

Treatment Differences:

When it comes to treatment mechanisms, TMS sets itself apart with its magnetic precision. Utilizing magnetic pulses, TMS precisely activates specific brain regions without inducing seizures. This approach, characterized by its non-invasiveness and targeted nature, delicately influences neural activity. In contrast, ECT relies on electrical currents to induce seizures, operating on a broader and less precise mechanism than TMS.

Side Effects: TMS vs ECT

Image showing a person's head losing puzzle pieces from brain to indicate memory loss/confusion

Considering side effects, TMS is linked to minimal adverse effects such as mild discomfort or headaches. Importantly, it avoids the memory loss or cognitive impairments often associated with ECT. Conversely, ECT comes with significant side effects, including more common and severe memory loss and cognitive impairments compared to TMS.

Administration Differences: Outpatient and Hospital

The administration process serves as another distinguishing factor between the two therapies. TMS is an outpatient procedure that does not necessitate anesthesia or hospitalization, allowing for an immediate return to daily activities. In contrast, ECT is typically administered in a hospital setting and requires anesthesia, with recovery potentially taking several hours, causing disruptions to daily life.

Treatment Path: Beginning to End Results

When examining the treatment course, TMS involves daily sessions over several weeks, with the option for maintenance sessions, offering a well-tolerated and continuous approach. On the other side, ECT demands a more intensive initial phase, coupled with variable maintenance sessions.

Image with a hand writing the text 'results' in marker

Effectiveness and relapse rates further set TMS and ECT apart. TMS has demonstrated efficacy in treating depression with lower relapse rates and milder side effects compared to ECT. While ECT can prove highly effective in cases for severe depression, it carries a higher risk of relapse and a potential for severe side effects.

Let's Summarize!

Understanding these differences holds paramount importance in making informed decisions regarding mental health treatment. Misinterpretations could lead to inaccurate expectations and inappropriate choices. By grasping these nuances, individuals can make informed decisions, ensuring a more effective and tailored approach to mental well-being.


Many people confuse these two therapy treatments quite often, but they really couldn't be any different! TMS Therapy is a more natural way to reach the root cause of depression through thorough brain mapping, several sessions for safety and efficacy, and NO harmful side effects! Thinking this treatment option for your depression is the way to go, let's try it! Together. Call or text our clinic today and see how we can help you with your mental health goals.

Mental health treatmentsTranscranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)TMSElectroconvulsive Therapy (ECT)ECTSide effects of TMS and ECTTreatment options for depressionTreatment options for anxiety/depressionWhat is the difference between ECT and TMS TherapyHow long is TMS TherapyMedication free treatment options for depression
Back to Blog

What Patients Say

"Absolutely best Doctor that I have ever had. Very knowledgeable, innovative, and most importantly, very caring and concerned for his patients best interest!! He actually listens and doesn’t attempt to use a one size fits all attitude. Definitely an out of the box thinker. So very sincerely grateful for him. ❤️ A life saver on a multitude of levels!! Thank you Doc!"

Image

Sharon B.

Saratoga Springs

"I highly recommend Dr. Manuel Astruc for his exceptional work in providing Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) treatments. I have been a patient of

Dr. Astruc for almost a year, receiving TMS treatments, and have experienced significant improvements in my mental health and overall well-being."

Image

Chelsea F.

Saratoga Springs

FAQ

What is TMS?

TMS (Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation) therapy is a non-invasive and FDA-approved treatment for various mental health conditions, including depression, anxiety, and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). This therapy uses magnetic fields to stimulate nerve cells in the brain, which can alleviate symptoms and improve overall well-being.

What is EEG?

EEG stands for Electroencephalogram. It's a test that measures electrical activity in the brain through small electrodes placed on the scalp, often used to diagnose neurological disorders or study brain function. It is used to identify the location, severity, and frequency of dysregulation in the brain. It can be very valuable when used along side TMS, and as a Quantitative EEG. This is when a normative database is used to compare the patient's brain activity to healthy brains at the same age.

FAQ image

How does TMS work?

TMS therapy works by using magnetic fields to stimulate specific areas of the brain that are associated with mood regulation and emotional processing. During a TMS session, a magnetic coil is placed against the scalp, and a rapidly changing magnetic field is generated, which induces an electrical current in the brain. This current can activate nerve cells that may not be functioning correctly, leading to improvements in symptoms related to depression, anxiety, and other mental health conditions. The exact mechanism by which TMS therapy produces its beneficial effects is still being studied, but it is believed to involve changes in neural plasticity and the release of neurotransmitters in the brain.

Is TMS for me?

Whether TMS therapy is right for you depends on various factors, including your specific symptoms, medical history, and treatment goals. TMS therapy has been shown to be effective for many individuals with depression, anxiety, and other mental health conditions, particularly those who have not responded well to traditional treatments such as medications or psychotherapy. However, it is important to consult with a healthcare professional to determine whether TMS therapy is a suitable option for you. A consultation with a TMS specialist can help you learn more about the treatment, its potential benefits, and whether it may be a good fit for your individual needs.

What does TMS feel like?

During a TMS (Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation) therapy session, you may feel a tapping or clicking sensation on your scalp where the magnetic coil is placed. This tapping sensation is typically painless and generally well-tolerated by most individuals. Some people also report feeling a mild headache or scalp discomfort during or after the treatment, but these side effects are usually temporary and go away shortly after the session is completed.

It's important to note that everyone's experience with TMS therapy is different, and some people may not experience any discomfort at all. If you have concerns about potential side effects or discomfort during TMS therapy, it's best to speak with a TMS specialist who can provide more detailed information and address any questions you may have.

Are there any side effects?

TMS (Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation) therapy is generally considered to be a safe and well-tolerated treatment for mental health conditions such as depression, anxiety, and obsessive-compulsive disorder. However, like any medical procedure, TMS therapy may be associated with some potential side effects.

Common side effects of TMS therapy include mild headache, scalp discomfort, and muscle twitching or spasms in the face or jaw during the session. These side effects are typically mild and short-lived, and can be managed with over-the-counter pain medication if needed.

Rarely, more serious side effects such as seizures or mania may occur, but these are extremely rare and typically only occur in individuals with certain pre-existing medical conditions. It's important to discuss any potential risks or concerns with a healthcare professional before starting TMS therapy.

Overall, TMS therapy is a safe and well-tolerated treatment option for many people with mental health conditions, and the benefits of the treatment generally outweigh the potential risks or side effects.

Is TMS covered by insurance?

Many insurance plans do cover TMS (Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation) therapy, but coverage varies depending on the specific plan and insurance provider. Some insurance plans may cover the full cost of TMS therapy, while others may cover only a portion of the cost or require a copayment or deductible.

It's always a good idea to check with your insurance provider to see if TMS therapy is covered under your plan and what your out-of-pocket costs may be. Some TMS clinics also offer assistance with insurance coverage and can help you navigate the insurance process.

What Patients Say

"Absolutely best Doctor that I have ever had. Very knowledgeable, innovative, and most importantly, very caring and concerned for his patients best interest!! He actually listens and doesn’t attempt to use a one size fits all attitude. Definitely an out of the box thinker. So very sincerely grateful for him. ❤️ A life saver on a multitude of levels!! Thank you Doc!"

Image

Sharon B.

Saratoga Springs

"I highly recommend Dr. Manuel Astruc for his exceptional work in providing Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) treatments. I have been a patient of

Dr. Astruc for almost a year, receiving TMS treatments, and have experienced significant improvements in my mental health and overall well-being."

Image

Chelsea F.

Saratoga Springs

We Accept Insurance

We are not in network with Fidelis, Medicare, or Humana at this time.

Contact your insurance provider to find how TMS is covered for you, as well as what fees you might be responsible for.

Come Join Us And Take Care Of Your Mental Health

Join us now and begin the positive change you deserve.

Our Services

Explore and book live and on-demand Yoga, Meditation and Art Therapy classes across the globe

Therapy

(234)

Yoga

(234)

Meditation

(234)

Success Stories

Discover the experiences of our patients who have undergone TMS therapy.

Sabrina

"I not only feel much better, I was able to get to know the amazing staff at the office! I feel alive again. I am so glad I decided to give it a try. I am so glad finished all the sessions. It works!"

Brycen

Your Paragraph text goes Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit. Autem dolore, alias, numquam enim ab voluptate id quam harum ducimus cupiditate similique quisquam et deserunt, recusandae. here

Meditation

Your Paragraph text goes Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit. Autem dolore, alias, numquam enim ab voluptate id quam harum ducimus cupiditate similique quisquam et deserunt, recusandae. here

Feel the relaxing Sensation

Private group

Join us as a member of a private group that will practice every

week and feel the benefits.

Pleasant situation

A pleasant atmosphere makes you enjoy doing yoga and focus on doing it.

Adequate tools

A pleasant atmosphere makes you enjoy doing yoga and focus on doing it.

Come Join Us And Take Care Of Your

Mental Health

Ready to take charge of your mental health journey?

Join us now and begin the positive change you deserve.

Social Media Links

Contact Us

414 Maple Ave #700b,

Saratoga Springs, NY 12866

©2024 – Manuel Astruc, M.D. & Associates | All Right Reserved

Social Media Links

Contact Us

414 Maple Ave #700b,

Saratoga Springs, NY 12866

©2024 – Manuel Astruc, M.D. & Associates | All Right Reserved